Skip to content
East River Park Action: Advocating for the health of the Lower East Side and the plent with science-based solutions
Menu
  • Home
    • Who We Are and Our Goals
  • News, History, Resources
    • East River Park News 2023/2024/2025
      • East River Park News 2022
      • East River Park News 2021
      • East River Park News 2020
      • East River Park News 2018-2019
    • History and Resources
      • History and Resources
      • Videos/Photos
        • Videos/Photos
        • Endangered Environs
      • Whaddya Want Anyway?
      • Cover the FDR
      • Legal
        • Alienated, reasons we sued, 2019
          • Alienation Lawsuit denied 8/20
          • Alienation denied, reasons for appeal
          • Alienation Lawsuit Appeal documents
          • Court orders, defied
          • Lawsuit Filed for Unredacted Value Engineering Report
      • Value Engineering
        • Value Engineering, Redacted
        • Resolved: No Value No Plan
      • Not One Sandbag
        • Not One Sandbag Part 2
      • The Rivers Beneath the Streets
    • Resiliency News from Everywhere
      • Resiliency News from Everywhere
      • East Side Coastal Resiliency Alternative Resources
  • Breathe
    • Breathe
    • LES Breathe
    • Sensors
    • Bad Air Days
    • Open Air Quality
    • Soil Foil
  • Synthetic Grass
    • Synthetic Grass
    • Synthetic Turf News
    • Research links on Artificial Turf
    • Proposed Real Grass Legislation in New York
    • Artificial Turf spills into East River, Lower East Side
    • Unnatural fields installed, East River Park, 2024
    • Temperatures of Artificial Turf, Lower East Side,
  • DONATE
  • Posts
  • ACTIONS NOW!
Menu

Value Engineering, Redacted

Posted on February 28, 2021March 6, 2021 by East River Park ACTION

Wait, wait, there is a Value Engineering Study. 

That’s the report the de Blasio administration cited in 2018 when they announced a change in the flood control plan for East River Park that would double the cost and bury the entire park in eight feet of fill. Yet when we submitted a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) request to see the Value Engineering Study, the city said the report didn’t exist…

… until we appealed. On Feb. 11, the NYC Department of Design and Construction finally released the three-year-old study. But, the report is heavily redacted. Here’s a good page. Note that the disadvantages outweigh the advantages:


We need to see an un-redacted report. We also strongly support the  NYC Group of the Sierra Club, which “calls upon the City Council’s Committees on Environmental Protection and the Council’s Parks and Recreation Committee to hold a joint oversight hearing on the East River Coastal Resiliency Project or ESCR” to get to the bottom of the “secrecy, inadequacy, and sequence of events and information releases [that] have left many perplexed and disturbed.” (Sierra Club letter link to pdf below)

We still need answers to our vital questions:

  • Is the East Side Coastal Resiliency even a viable plan? 
  • Will it reduce construction time? There have already been many delays.
  • Can it really be done for the budgeted $1.45 billion? Thus far, even the lowest contractors’ bids exceed the city’s estimates.Is the giant proposed levee really going to hold back the water into the next century?
  • Are there other solutions that will provide equal flood protection for our neighborhood without completely destroying our 82-year old park?
  • Will the dust and impacts of construction damage the health of neighborhood residents?
  • Why won’t the city reevaluate its refusal to provide any interim flood protection during the years of construction? 

Our many ACTIONeers have pored over the plans and have found fatal flawsthat will damage our neighborhood’s well being for years to come. We must have transparency, accountability, and community involvement in a revised plan.

Please donate to our legal fund to make sure we get the plan we deserve, not this unjust boondoggle that will enrich a few and cause misery in the Lower East Side and East Village. 


Value Engineering Links

The 347-page Value Engineering Study for the Office of Management and Budget is available here: https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/escr/downloads/pdf/ESCR-Value-Engineering-Study-Preliminary-Report-2018.pdf

The 31-page Report of Findings is available here: 
https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/escr/downloads/pdf/ESCR-Elevated-Park-Alternative-Feasibility-Analysis-2018.pdf

Read the New York Post’s coverage by Melissa Klein, February 27, 2021, New York POST:

NYC finally releases East River Park report, with heavy redactions

”The lack of transparency in this $1.45 billion public project is unconscionable. These redactions are just a pattern of disdain that the city has shown toward our community,” said Tommy Loeb, a member of East River Park Action. 

The city used the value engineering report as the basis for ditching another flood protection plan that would not have decimated the 57-acre park. The report says the plan to raise the level of the park would save $319 million.

Sierra Club Letter

2021-2-18 Sierra Club Urges a HearingDownload

East River Park Action Letter

ERPA – letterDownload

Foil Appeal by attorney

2021-3-2 FOILAppeal-DDC-JLDownload
  • east river park
  • East Side Coastal Resiliency
  • erpax
  • fatal flaws
  • sierra club nyc
  • Value Engineering Report
  • Value Engineering Study
  • 4 thoughts on “Value Engineering, Redacted”

    1. Steve Sands says:
      April 18, 2021 at 12:51 am

      It’s incredible how the city spends our tax dollars and wastes Court time to keep the taxpayers in the dark on how decisions are made. I myself have targeted corrupt offices overseen by De Blasio’s office who are extremely FOUL challenged. We need to change FOIL laws to prohibit redaction loopholes that obfuscate tge ttuth.

      Reply
    2. H says:
      April 22, 2021 at 9:24 am

      What are mayoral candidates positions on all this???? Should be on their agenda.

      Reply
    3. Maya Chafe says:
      June 5, 2021 at 6:04 pm

      Hello H- I dont know what the views if the mayoral candidates are on the ESRP, as the city calls it: their “preferred plan” (not preferred by most EV residents!) but MBP candidate Lindsay Boylan (D, Progressive) has spoken out against it and so will be getting my vote! As her volunteer texted me: “She’s a huge supporter of saving east river park – she’s done a number of events with east river park action and has been incredibly vocal on the issue. Yesterday at the MBP debate, she was the only one to speak out in support of it.”
      Here’s hoping! Please post anything you can learn regarding other candidates on this page.
      Thanks,
      Maya

      Reply
    4. Pat says:
      June 5, 2021 at 7:51 pm

      Thank you for your cogent comment.

      Reply

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Subscribe

    Our Air Quality Now

    We have three air quality monitors on the Lower East Side. See them at Purple Air.

    Help Save East River Park

    Contribute to our nonprofit East River Park Action
    using PayPal or a credit card.
    You can use the dropdown menu to choose:
    * LES Breathe (air monitoring and environment)
    * Legal Fund (for accountability and transparency)
    * Raising Hell (demand a better park!)

    Be There!

    Visit our ACTIONS NOW! page to find out what you can do to help the health and livability of our Lower East Side.

    The Latest

    • Support Howard Brandstein April 16, 2025
    • Grassroots for “Touch Grass” bill April 9, 2025
    • No Power December 29, 2024
    • Synthetic Grass September 16, 2024
    • Unnatural September 10, 2024
    Instagram icon
    Instagram. Click the logo above.

    Bluesky

    Facebook

    X

     

    This Lenapehoking Land

    East River Park is forever Indigenous land of Lenapehoking. We  honor and respect the land of this park by advocating for its renewal as a biodiverse, healthful ecosystem. 

    NYS Constitutional Amendment for Environmental Rights: "Each person shall have a right to clean air and water, and a healthful environment.”

    • Home
      • Who We Are and Our Goals
    • News, History, Resources
      • East River Park News 2023/2024/2025
        • East River Park News 2022
        • East River Park News 2021
        • East River Park News 2020
        • East River Park News 2018-2019
      • History and Resources
        • History and Resources
        • Videos/Photos
          • Videos/Photos
          • Endangered Environs
        • Whaddya Want Anyway?
        • Cover the FDR
        • Legal
          • Alienated, reasons we sued, 2019
            • Alienation Lawsuit denied 8/20
            • Alienation denied, reasons for appeal
            • Alienation Lawsuit Appeal documents
            • Court orders, defied
            • Lawsuit Filed for Unredacted Value Engineering Report
        • Value Engineering
          • Value Engineering, Redacted
          • Resolved: No Value No Plan
        • Not One Sandbag
          • Not One Sandbag Part 2
        • The Rivers Beneath the Streets
      • Resiliency News from Everywhere
        • Resiliency News from Everywhere
        • East Side Coastal Resiliency Alternative Resources
    • Breathe
      • Breathe
      • LES Breathe
      • Sensors
      • Bad Air Days
      • Open Air Quality
      • Soil Foil
    • Synthetic Grass
      • Synthetic Grass
      • Synthetic Turf News
      • Research links on Artificial Turf
      • Proposed Real Grass Legislation in New York
      • Artificial Turf spills into East River, Lower East Side
      • Unnatural fields installed, East River Park, 2024
      • Temperatures of Artificial Turf, Lower East Side,
    • DONATE
    • Posts
    • ACTIONS NOW!
    © 2025 East River Park ACTION | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme