Skip to content
East River Park Action: Advocating for the health of the Lower East Side and the plent with science-based solutions
Menu
  • Home
    • Who We Are and Our Goals
  • News, History, Resources
    • East River Park News 2023/2024/2025
      • East River Park News 2022
      • East River Park News 2021
      • East River Park News 2020
      • East River Park News 2018-2019
    • History and Resources
      • History and Resources
      • Videos/Photos
        • Videos/Photos
        • Endangered Environs
      • Whaddya Want Anyway?
      • Cover the FDR
      • Legal
        • Alienated, reasons we sued, 2019
          • Alienation Lawsuit denied 8/20
          • Alienation denied, reasons for appeal
          • Alienation Lawsuit Appeal documents
          • Court orders, defied
          • Lawsuit Filed for Unredacted Value Engineering Report
      • Value Engineering
        • Value Engineering, Redacted
        • Resolved: No Value No Plan
      • Not One Sandbag
        • Not One Sandbag Part 2
      • The Rivers Beneath the Streets
    • Resiliency News from Everywhere
      • Resiliency News from Everywhere
      • East Side Coastal Resiliency Alternative Resources
  • Breathe
    • Breathe
    • LES Breathe
    • Sensors
    • Bad Air Days
    • Open Air Quality
    • Soil Foil
  • Synthetic Grass
    • Synthetic Grass
    • Synthetic Turf News
    • Research links on Artificial Turf
    • Proposed Real Grass Legislation in New York
    • Artificial Turf spills into East River, Lower East Side
    • Unnatural fields installed, East River Park, 2024
    • Temperatures of Artificial Turf, Lower East Side,
  • DONATE
  • Posts
  • ACTIONS NOW!
Menu

There was a plan, and we want it back

Posted on August 27, 2019October 18, 2019 by East River Park ACTION

It gave us flood protection and didn’t kill our park

The Big U was part of a larger plan to protect Lower Manhattan, and our community helped develop it over four years. The city trashed it in late 2018. Now the city is going to trash our entire park and close it for years. Here was the plan the community approved for our park:

“In East River Park, an undulating berm at the location of the service road to the FDR Drive provides flood protection. The berm is shaped so that the existing sports fields can be maintained. Generous landscaped bridges will connect the East River Park to the community. The flood protection continues to Montgomery Street by fortifying the new Pier 42 Park, where a deployable will help maintain the on-ramp to the FDR Drive.”

“The flood protection in East River Park protects $780,000,000 in potential damages (NPV). With a design height of 15ft, the system has a benefit-cost ratio of 2.08.”

Green Infrastructure

“Green infrastructure in all three compartments contributes to both flood protection and social amenities in the Big U. Climate-change models predict more frequent heavy-precipitation events, leading to even more street flooding and combined sewer overflows (CSO) than we have already experienced in our largely water- impervious city. The urban heat island effect will be exacerbated by longer heat waves. The Big U’s native species bio-swales, rain gardens, and street plantings will absorb and clean stormwater, cool the city, reduce air pollution, store carbon, buffer noise, enhance recreational activities, improve mental health, and provide green jobs. As a by-product of these benefits, they will also save the City and its residents money, for example in healthcare.”

The city says the new plan that will demolish the park is better because it will take 3 1/2 years rather than the five years for the Big U plan. No one believes that the park can be demolished and rebuilt eight feet higher in 3 1/2 years. The city is going to spend $1.45 billion on the new plan. (Since this was first published, the timeline has changed. In October, the mayor announced the construction would be phased so parts of the park would remain open throughout construction. The timeline is now five years. The same as the Big U plan. So, uh, hello Mr. Mayor? Can you go back to that and not demolish our park?)

The old plan should be resurrected and revised as needed.

For the Summary of the Big U in pdf format, click the link here.

Here’s a comparison compiled by Wendy Brawer of the earlier plan and the current plan:

Key differences in East Side Coastal Resiliency (ESCR) Alt 2 (community engaged plan, 3/18) to Alt 4 (3/19 City Plan Summary). The ESCR has continually evolved.

• Original groundbreaking scheduled for 2017, then spring 2019. Now fall 2020

●  Alt 2 was $445 Million. Costs escalated to $1.45 billion with Alt 4

●  Esplanade was to remain open throughout construction for community use. Alt 4 closes and destroys the entire park

●  Room for surging water, salt-water resistant and native planting. (12/18 Stewardship planning report by consultants, convened by Rebuild byDesign and GOLES, with community members, was released just when Alt 4 appeared.

●  Artificial Wetlands were to be established, as developed by Lower East Side Ecology Center

●  West edge of East River Park was to be bermed with rolling hills, grand bridge entrances, seating and greenway etc, plus walls and deployablewalls where needed. Alt 2 does not taper down to overlook FDR Drive on western third of park, nor place cyclists next to FDR lanes

●  Passive space was not to be reduced nearly 3 acres. Alt 4 expands tennis courts and parking, replaces all turf fields.

●  DEIS indicates Alt 2 removes 265 trees, Alt 3 removes 766 trees. Alt 4 removes 981 trees (including all in floodplain).

●  Alt 2 did not destroy and rebuild amphitheater, Seal plaza, Ecology Center, embayments, new bridge ramp (Williamsburg), fitness area, etc

●  Upland areas (extending to much of CB3, and especially NYCHA campuses) were to have new street trees, bioswales, absorbent green space

●  There was not a new bridge at Corlears. Flyover discussed since Blue Way Plan (great ideas – elevated paths for using park while wet)

●  Failure of the new bulkheads was not anticipated (should ESCR contractor be liable for a longer time?). Alt 4 has reconstruction of drainagesystem and sewer outfalls, pump houses (but not separation of combined sewerage to prevent water pollution)



  • Big U
  • east river park
  • Flood control
  • Lower East Side
  • 1 thought on “There was a plan, and we want it back”

    1. Francis Anthony Schiro says:
      August 27, 2019 at 10:39 pm

      100% TOTALLY UNACCEPTABLE… address the core issues of global warming…GET REAL… LEAVE our park alone. Be warned.

      Reply

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Subscribe

    Our Air Quality Now

    We have three air quality monitors on the Lower East Side. See them at Purple Air.

    Be There!

    Visit our ACTIONS NOW! page to find out what you can do to help the health and livability of our Lower East Side.

    The Latest

    • Our Park May 26, 2025
    • Support Howard Brandstein April 16, 2025
    • Grassroots for “Touch Grass” bill April 9, 2025
    • No Power December 29, 2024
    • Synthetic Grass September 16, 2024
    Instagram icon
    Instagram. Click the logo above.

    Bluesky

    Facebook

    X

     

    This Lenapehoking Land

    East River Park is forever Indigenous land of Lenapehoking. We  honor and respect the land of this park by advocating for its renewal as a biodiverse, healthful ecosystem. 

    NYS Constitutional Amendment for Environmental Rights: "Each person shall have a right to clean air and water, and a healthful environment.”

    Help Save East River Park

    Contribute to our nonprofit East River Park Action
    using PayPal or a credit card.
    You can use the dropdown menu to choose:
    * LES Breathe (air monitoring and environment)
    * Legal Fund (for accountability and transparency)
    * Raising Hell (demand a better park!)
    • Home
      • Who We Are and Our Goals
    • News, History, Resources
      • East River Park News 2023/2024/2025
        • East River Park News 2022
        • East River Park News 2021
        • East River Park News 2020
        • East River Park News 2018-2019
      • History and Resources
        • History and Resources
        • Videos/Photos
          • Videos/Photos
          • Endangered Environs
        • Whaddya Want Anyway?
        • Cover the FDR
        • Legal
          • Alienated, reasons we sued, 2019
            • Alienation Lawsuit denied 8/20
            • Alienation denied, reasons for appeal
            • Alienation Lawsuit Appeal documents
            • Court orders, defied
            • Lawsuit Filed for Unredacted Value Engineering Report
        • Value Engineering
          • Value Engineering, Redacted
          • Resolved: No Value No Plan
        • Not One Sandbag
          • Not One Sandbag Part 2
        • The Rivers Beneath the Streets
      • Resiliency News from Everywhere
        • Resiliency News from Everywhere
        • East Side Coastal Resiliency Alternative Resources
    • Breathe
      • Breathe
      • LES Breathe
      • Sensors
      • Bad Air Days
      • Open Air Quality
      • Soil Foil
    • Synthetic Grass
      • Synthetic Grass
      • Synthetic Turf News
      • Research links on Artificial Turf
      • Proposed Real Grass Legislation in New York
      • Artificial Turf spills into East River, Lower East Side
      • Unnatural fields installed, East River Park, 2024
      • Temperatures of Artificial Turf, Lower East Side,
    • DONATE
    • Posts
    • ACTIONS NOW!
    © 2025 East River Park ACTION | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme